One critic’s view: “The two craptastic songs that American Idol 5 finalists Taylor Hicks and Katharine McPhee performed Tuesday night were, unbelievably, the best two songs in a pool of 150 possibilities. … All five [of the writers of these two songs] deserve eternal scorn and shame, or at least membership in the Diane Warren Hall of Mediocre Pop Songs.” – Andy Dehnart @ reality blurred
The public’s view: 1.79 / 5.00, the second-worst #1 hit of 2006
Winning American Idol in the 2000s was like boarding a spaceship and blasting into the outer reaches of fame. The champion soars through the atmosphere at Mach 10, watching through the window as the Earth’s mighty cities, mountains, and rivers bow down before his greatness. He is living his dream for a moment, but then the booster rocket malfunctions as it is supposed to lift his celebrity status into a stable orbit. He opens the door to the engine compartment to see what is wrong, and discovers that someone has emptied a trash can into the space where the ignition module is supposed to be. Amid the gum wrappers and orange peels he finds the script for From Justin to Kelly and the sheet music for “This Is the Night”. Gravity soon does its thing, and he ends his brief flight by splashing down into the Pacific. He never quite becomes a pop star, but he goes back to his hometown and his job at Winn-Dixie with a great story to tell for the rest of his life.
Kelly Clarkson and Carrie Underwood were able to avoid this scenario, as both of them escaped the shadows of the mediocre adult contemporary ballads they were forced to perform for their first singles. However, neither had to contend with “Do I Make You Proud”, which was assigned to Taylor Hicks in season five. This was debatably the worst coronation song for any Idol winner (or second-place finisher) up to that point, and it was some fairly heavy ballast to bring along on a career-launching rocket ride.
“Do I Make You Proud” starts out as a standard soft rock gewgaw, but then builds to a powerful chorus with a memorable hook. Unfortunately, the reason the chorus is memorable is that it sounds like a previous #1 hit: Aerosmith’s “I Don’t Want to Miss a Thing”. Now, I am sure that music experts can point out dozens of ways in which the two songs are different. “Taylor Hicks’s bass player employs an innovative left-handed tuning scheme that elevates the rhythmic feel of the piece. Also, Hicks’s melody has a tilde over the A-flat in the second measure – a jarring contrast from Aerosmith’s arpeggio.” But to my uninformed ears, these are essentially the same choruses with different lyrics.
Let’s talk about those lyrics, which focus on the singer’s one nagging concern: he needs to know if the listeners are proud of him. It’s unreasonable for him to expect that of us. Unless I’m Taylor Hicks’s singing coach or his mother, why should I be proud that he got a trophy in a televised contest? His fans may have felt contentment, relief, or even sexual pleasure when he won Idol, but I doubt that any of them truly took pride in an achievement that wasn’t theirs. Perhaps he’s talking about pride of representation, as with Black Pride or Gay Pride. Hicks isn’t black or gay, but he is an ambassador for the Men With Prematurely Graying Hair movement. However, as a card-carrying member of the MWPGH community, I can report that we used up all of our representational pride on Steve Martin and Phil Donahue back around 1980. We don’t have any left for Taylor Hicks.
The first verse contains the line “My heart is full of endless gratitude.” Logically, I expect the next line to be “That I got to see you in the nude.” (“And I’m a handsome gray-haired dude” would also work.) Instead, the line is “You were the one, the one to guide me through.” Maybe I should be pleased that the songwriters didn’t go for the obvious rhyme. Instead I’m annoyed that they didn’t bother to rhyme the line correctly at all, yet still came up with something boring and trite.
Hicks’s performance on “Do I Make You Proud” gives me the sense that he is not just a technically proficient singer like all of the other Idol winners. He also has some soulfulness and passion, and I might enjoy listening to him in another context. Too bad that the song demotivates me from wanting to seek out his other music.
No comments:
Post a Comment